Sometimes challenges have unexpected solutions. In this case I created a challenge, play-tested it and then decided to change it a bit to make it more attractive. However, my changes gave way to a slew of really easy unintended solutions. So where this challenge was meant to teach you about time based blind SQL injections, it turned out to be just a very simple straightforward SQL injection.
What you will learn:
- Identify SQL injections when there are not error messages
SLEEP()to extract data, character for character
So, there are at least 3 solutions to this challenge. Lets walk through them, from intended solution to unintended ones.
The challenge starts with a new interface, the Santabase and the user has the option to search by username to retrieve data from the naughty list. These are all hints to the names of objects in the database.
Searching for anything in the database will yield empty results, unless you have the right username of course. The empty resultset has a header Why?. This is important as any correctly formatted query will result in an empty table.
When entering anything that breaks the query, the result will not contain the Why? header. This is the clue that is left in order to construct a proper SQL query. As there is nothing else that can be used to retrieve information a more creative use of SQL is necessary.
A test query that can be utilized here is
' or (select sleep(1)); #. This will cause the retrieval to last at least 1 second. In case you have a slow internet connection it might be necessary to increate the 1 to a higher number to notice the delay correctly.
As it is known that the
username column is searched in the
naughty table (or list) a query can be constructed that will take the value of
username character by character to compare it against a known set. If it matches, the sleep can be used to indicate a match and else the query will return instantly.
First, to get a single character from a field the
mid() function can be used. In this case the following expression
mid(username,1,1 will return the first character from the field username. Also
substr() might be used, which was learned in the previous challenge. I like to use
mid() as it is shorter.
In order to get a sense of the data the query needs to sleep when it matches a character. This can be achieved by using an
if() expression. The first parameter will be the match, the thing that says true or false on a match, the 2nd parameter is the thing that happens when they match, in this case
sleep(1) and the 3rd parameter will be the thing that happens when there is no match. For now we can simply return
Putting it all together creates the following listing. The username is check to see if the first character of
username is an
a. If it is, it will sleep 1 second and else return instantly.
' or (select if(mid(username,1,1)='a', sleep(1), 0) from naughty); #
Using this strategy the full username can be retrieved from the database. It takes quite some queries, but it has been retrieved.
' or (select if(mid(username,1,1)='e', sleep(1), 0) from naughty); # ' or (select if(mid(username,2,1)='g', sleep(1), 0) from naughty); # ' or (select if(mid(username,3,1)='i', sleep(1), 0) from naughty); # ' or (select if(mid(username,4,1)='s', sleep(1), 0) from naughty); # ' or (select if(mid(username,5,1)='c', sleep(1), 0) from naughty); # ' or (select if(mid(username,6,1)='h', sleep(1), 0) from naughty); # ' or (select if(mid(username,7,1)='e', sleep(1), 0) from naughty); #
Entering the username will show the flag in the Why? table. The flag can be used to retrieve the points and the badge.
Unintended Solution 1
Due to my editing of the challenge to make it more stack-able from a knowledge point of view I inadvertently created one of the easiest challenges in the entire game. The most basic SQL injection actually showed the flag to the user.
' or 1=1 #
Unintended Solution 2
Getting the flag alone is an accomplishment, however knowing the username is the real thing in this challenge. Due to the same reason that the first unintended solution exists, there is an obvious way to grab this data with the UNION SELECT from the previous challenge. Using this query the username is shown in the Why? table.
' UNION SELECT username FROM naughty #
Go back to the homepage.